You Are Here: Home » Responsa Resource » Shabbat » taking out garbage on Shabbos follow up question

taking out garbage on Shabbos follow up question

Question:
Thank you very much for your reply to my question regarding the removal of garbage on Shabbos. Is it possible to clarify one point.When I throw out a disposable plate into the garbage and now it becomes disgusting, would the plate still retain its non muktzeh status? What about the edible food which I will not take out to give the dog, (I assume since I do not own one) because it became disgusting in the garbage. would the scraps remain non muktzeh? )
what would be if the scraps stayed overnight and are spoiled since they were out?

Thank you so much
Answer:

A plate which was thrown out on Shabbos but is still usable if it would be washed off, is a matter of debate as to whether it becomes muktzeh. The same is true with regards to dog edible food scraps in a place where dogs are commonly found [even if you do not own one]. So when the garbage contains empty bottles and plates etc. we can assume this does not make it a bosis.

Spoiled food which is unfit for even dogs becomes muktzah.

 

Leave a Comment

Scroll to top