You Are Here: Home » Posts tagged "eilu v’eilu"

Eilu V’Eilu

Question: Does the principle of אלו ואלו דברי אלקים חיים apply in a historical מחלוקת about what happened? For example, whether the תורה was originally given in כתב אשורית or כתב עברי? Or when two אמוראים argue about what the תנא said? Answer: It would seem that the rule of אלו ואלו דבדרי אלקים חיים would apply to debates pertaining to clarifying a question of halacha. The fact that the practical halacha si ...

Read more
Scroll to top